Big three Diesel Shootout

Use this forum for technical questions regarding tow vehicles.

Moderators: Mike Clay, Olbird

Post Reply
User avatar
gmarker
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 11:11 am
Location: Texas Cedar Park
Cardinal Owners: 2005 29WBLE
Location: Texas Cedar Park

Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by gmarker »

Anyone thinking about getting a new TV might be find this ( http://wardsauto.com/ar/ford_power_diesel_100920/ ) article interesting. I am a total Ford man, but am extremely impressed with the new trucks from all three manufacturers. Looks to me like any of them would be a good choice.
GERRY & KAY
2005 29WBLE
20011 FORD F250 LARIOT 6.7 POWERSTROKE
MAX the WONDERCAT
User avatar
Mike Clay
Council, Administrator
Posts: 13246
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:53 am
Location: Oregon Gresham
Cardinal Owners: 2016 3850RL Estate
Skype ID: Mike-Clay
Location: Oregon Gresham

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Mike Clay »

Well good for Ford :thumbrt: but I do disagree on this part: With the trailer attached, the Duramax feels (and sounds) like it needs to work harder than the Power Stroke to do the same job. Under heavy acceleration, the Duramax sounds downright shrill.

In one back-to-back test, the Duramax needs about 2,000 rpm to tow the trailer up a moderate grade. The Power Stroke in the Super Duty conquers the same grade at the same speed at about 1,300 rpm. The Ford engine feels like it is barely working at all.
In my real world test with the passes on the west coast and towing over 4k miles so far my fan has only come on two times temp never gets above 205 on the water. Dont get me wrong I am glad Ford seems to have their engine problems fixed and have a good product. These tests kill me, take into consideration where the sweet spot for the cummins, ford and gmc are. They are all different with different trannys so that statement really does not hold much water, with me anyway. But thats what makes the world go round :D
Mike, Susanna & Rudy
2016 3850RL Estate "Proto Grigio"
2019 Silverado 3500HD Dually D/A 4x4 LTZ
My dreams are too big for my wallet
Rallies attended - 32

Nights camping in 2013:159 2014:269 2015:Full Timers
Torben

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Torben »

I am with you all the way, Mike. :thumbrt: I am standing by my Duramax :thumbrt: :thumbrt: :thumbrt:
User avatar
gmarker
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 11:11 am
Location: Texas Cedar Park
Cardinal Owners: 2005 29WBLE
Location: Texas Cedar Park

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by gmarker »

Can't argue with anything you said, Mike. If I had to pick the best one out of this years models, without knowing who the manufacturers were, it would be a tough choice. However, considering where my retirement check comes from, I guess I will stick with the Ford.
GERRY & KAY
2005 29WBLE
20011 FORD F250 LARIOT 6.7 POWERSTROKE
MAX the WONDERCAT
User avatar
Mike Clay
Council, Administrator
Posts: 13246
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:53 am
Location: Oregon Gresham
Cardinal Owners: 2016 3850RL Estate
Skype ID: Mike-Clay
Location: Oregon Gresham

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Mike Clay »

LOL I can understand that Gerry
Mike, Susanna & Rudy
2016 3850RL Estate "Proto Grigio"
2019 Silverado 3500HD Dually D/A 4x4 LTZ
My dreams are too big for my wallet
Rallies attended - 32

Nights camping in 2013:159 2014:269 2015:Full Timers
User avatar
bigbunkhouse
Posts: 1105
Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2008 6:40 pm
Location: Massachusetts North Reading
Cardinal Owners: 2007 362BHS
Location: Massachusetts North Reading

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by bigbunkhouse »

cant go wrong with any of them! Just personal taste, we all have our reasons, mine comes from the fact that it seems that the Ford oval is part of our family crest or atleast it would seem that way with the generations of Ford only mantra. LOL
2007 362bhs Cardinal (The mobile vacation home)
99 f350 4dr dually v-10 Lb 2wd 4.30 locker (Big Dually)
Dogs: Elvis and Priscilla
Me (Matt), Wifey (Jana), (Julia)14 year old daughter and ***SHYANNE*** born 8/12/10
User avatar
TGADDIS
Posts: 16
Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 9:05 am
Location: Wyoming Laramie
Cardinal Owners: 2006 29RKLE
2011 GMC Sierra 3500HD
Location: Wyoming Laramie

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by TGADDIS »

I had the opportunity this week to test drive both the ford and the chevrolet. Being a dodge owner I feel I have an unbiased opinion and I must admit I was so impressed with the 2011 chevy that I placed an order for one.
Troy & Renee
2006 rkle
2017 GMC Sierra HD
Samsbird
Posts: 209
Joined: Thu May 06, 2010 5:46 pm
Location: Virginia Culpeper
Cardinal Owners: 35 sbqle fifth wheel
Skype ID: yes
Location: Virginia Culpeper

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Samsbird »

I'm with you man, that is a good article and it's good to see the new Powerstroke getting excellent reviews as people put more miles on them. I will be looking to trade my 6.0 in on one this time next year.

Randall
2009 35sbq fifth wheel
2012 F350 SRW King Ranch 6.7 Powerstroke
1969 (428 Super Cobra Jet Mach 1)
1970 (Boss 302)
User avatar
Mike Clay
Council, Administrator
Posts: 13246
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:53 am
Location: Oregon Gresham
Cardinal Owners: 2016 3850RL Estate
Skype ID: Mike-Clay
Location: Oregon Gresham

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Mike Clay »

TGADDIS wrote:I had the opportunity this week to test drive both the ford and the chevrolet. Being a dodge owner I feel I have an unbiased opinion and I must admit I was so impressed with the 2011 chevy that I placed an order for one.
:thumbrt: You will love it
Mike, Susanna & Rudy
2016 3850RL Estate "Proto Grigio"
2019 Silverado 3500HD Dually D/A 4x4 LTZ
My dreams are too big for my wallet
Rallies attended - 32

Nights camping in 2013:159 2014:269 2015:Full Timers
User avatar
TGADDIS
Posts: 16
Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 9:05 am
Location: Wyoming Laramie
Cardinal Owners: 2006 29RKLE
2011 GMC Sierra 3500HD
Location: Wyoming Laramie

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by TGADDIS »

I cant wait to get I'm like a kid at christmas my wife joked with the salesman he should have to live with me for the next 6 weeks.
Troy & Renee
2006 rkle
2017 GMC Sierra HD
User avatar
Olbird
Council, Asst. Admin
Posts: 4185
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 9:29 pm
Location: Washington Kelso
Cardinal Owners: 3850 RL
Location: Washington, LaCenter

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Olbird »

Have they come out with a 5th wheel hitch mount for the 2011 Chevy
George & Julie
3850 RL Full Paint w/ TrailAir Spring Ride System, Kodiak Disc Brakes, TrailAir Tri-Glide Pin Box, Over 130 Mods

2022 Ford F450 DRW
User avatar
gmarker
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 11:11 am
Location: Texas Cedar Park
Cardinal Owners: 2005 29WBLE
Location: Texas Cedar Park

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by gmarker »

Reese has them, but I don't know about the others.
GERRY & KAY
2005 29WBLE
20011 FORD F250 LARIOT 6.7 POWERSTROKE
MAX the WONDERCAT
User avatar
Olbird
Council, Asst. Admin
Posts: 4185
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 9:29 pm
Location: Washington Kelso
Cardinal Owners: 3850 RL
Location: Washington, LaCenter

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Olbird »

I think reese only has the flip over tube mount ball/hitch .
George & Julie
3850 RL Full Paint w/ TrailAir Spring Ride System, Kodiak Disc Brakes, TrailAir Tri-Glide Pin Box, Over 130 Mods

2022 Ford F450 DRW
User avatar
gmarker
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 11:11 am
Location: Texas Cedar Park
Cardinal Owners: 2005 29WBLE
Location: Texas Cedar Park

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by gmarker »

These people show 2011 Chevy kits for the Reese and Curt. http://www.etrailer.com/5w-2011_Chevrol ... 500+Series
GERRY & KAY
2005 29WBLE
20011 FORD F250 LARIOT 6.7 POWERSTROKE
MAX the WONDERCAT
User avatar
Olbird
Council, Asst. Admin
Posts: 4185
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 9:29 pm
Location: Washington Kelso
Cardinal Owners: 3850 RL
Location: Washington, LaCenter

Re: Big three Diesel Shootout

Post by Olbird »

Yes, I looked at the install instructions and that is how the new frames are built, glad to to see they came out with a mount kit before to many 2011truck owners had their trucks with no way to pull.
George & Julie
3850 RL Full Paint w/ TrailAir Spring Ride System, Kodiak Disc Brakes, TrailAir Tri-Glide Pin Box, Over 130 Mods

2022 Ford F450 DRW
Post Reply